Advertisements
The landscape of employment in the United States is poised for an extraordinary transformation in 2025, heralded by the most substantial adjustments to the non-farm payrolls in historyThis shift is set against the backdrop of sweeping changes in immigration data, with the labor force witnessing an anticipated uptick of around 2.3 million jobs due to wide-ranging annual revisions to household employment figures, as highlighted by the recent analyses from leading financial institutions.
On February 7, the U.SBureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) released the non-farm payroll report for January, which included pivotal annual benchmark revisions for its household surveyThese adjustments are monumental as they aim to amend any inaccuracies and lags in the previous household data, which can become misaligned due to demographic changes over timeWith hopes of aligning these figures more closely with the recently published census forecasts, the updated benchmarks will have significant implications for various employment metrics, labor force size, and the structure of the job market.
It is essential to delineate how the non-farm report is constructed
This report derives its data from two primary sources: the establishment survey, capturing employment figures from employers, and the household survey, gathering statistics about actual employment situations in homesHistorically, the establishment survey has shown a consistent trend of higher new job numbers compared to the household figures, which encompass a broader range of employment types.
The initial findings from this comprehensive readjustment have sparked discussions among economists, including insights from Goldman SachsIn a recent report, the firm pointed out that prior census data had vastly underestimated population growth over recent yearsIt suggested that the immigration estimates for 2023-2024 were overly reliant on outdated migration information from the 2022 American Community Survey, failing to account for the recent waves of immigrantsConsequently, this resulted in an underestimation of job growth in the household survey
A rectification in December indicated a substantial boost of 3.5 million in net immigration estimates for 2021-2024.
This adjustment aligns closely with Goldman Sachs' projection, which anticipates that as new data are incorporated into the employment reports, we will watch the non-institutional population soar by 3.5 million and household employment rise sharply by 2.3 million—marking an unparalleled adjustment in recorded historyIt is crucial to recognize that figures prior to 2025 will not see retroactive modifications, which allows this period of adjustment to create a clearer picture of current employment scenarios.
The revised calculations suggest dramatic overall impacts: an increase in the total labor force by approximately 2.5 million, with household employment following suit, contributing to labor force participation rates that could see an increase of 11 basis points and an accompanying rise of 4 basis points in the unemployment rate
Looking ahead, the U.SCensus Bureau forecasts a return to normalized population growth in 2025, approximating around 1.9 million.
The enormity of this adjustment cannot be understated, as it is anticipated to bridge the gap that has emerged since the surge in immigration that has marked the early years of 2022. Moreover, it is essential to acknowledge that there will be disproportionate effects on certain demographic groupsGoldman Sachs has cautiously noted that the reallocation of an additional 3.5 million residents among states, age brackets, genders, and racial groups is based on sampling data from immigration trends observed between 2019 and 2023. This is particularly interesting because, according to the 2023 American Community Survey report, these new immigrants are more likely to be young individuals from Hispanic or Asian backgrounds.
The ramifications of these demographic shifts are multi-faceted
Given the tendency of young Hispanic and Asian individuals to have higher labor force participation rates compared to their older counterparts, there is a potential for an increase in both the overall participation rate and the unemployment rateAs such, the demographic adjustments made to accommodate the new estimations will hinge significantly on these specific groups and their representation within the broader labor market metrics.
Post-revision expectations envision a net rise in the total labor force of 2.5 million, coupled with the household employment increase of 2.3 million, resulting in labor participation rates climbing by 11 basis points while signalling a modest rise in the unemployment rate of 4 basis pointsNotably, the Census Bureau estimates indicate that employment growth should stabilize to its prior norms, returning to approximately 1.9 million by 2025. This means the demographic and employment assumptions utilized in the household surveys are likely to realign with these more realistic growth benchmarks going into 2025.
However, Goldman Sachs has also sounded a note of caution regarding these adjustments; due to the lack of consideration for immigration status or birthplace during the census population redistribution process, variables such as participation and unemployment rates may not be entirely precise